Tootsi is a matte lippie described as a “cool-toned grey beige”. It is more of a satin matte, as the finish has a very slight sheen.
This pencil looks a lot different in the tube than it does on my lips. I’ve also seen others wear this and it looks more gray on them; on me, it definitely has a hint of rose/pink.
Tootsi is really pigmented and comfortable to wear. It is fairly long-lasting and just a flat out easy color to wear. It doesn’t dry out my lips, and it goes with practically everything.
Even in the swatch above, it appears pretty rosy! I don’t know if there were different shades in different batches, but it doesn’t matter to me; I really like this color. I’ve read that this is a limited edition shade (according to reviews), but a lot of people are begging for it to be permanent. I will probably get a back-up if this remains limited edition, because I would definitely repurchase this color.
Tootsi is one of ColourPop’s bestselling shades if you click on the “Best Sellers” link on their website. There is a matching lip liner for Tootsi, but I only have the lipstick. I love the matte formula of these lipsticks and will probably end up getting more in the future!